sábado, 21 de novembro de 2026

Observador - Carta aberta aos revolucionários da tenda

 


(sublinhados pessoais)

LBC - Uf!

Carta aberta aos revolucionários da tenda

Antes de libertardes a humanidade, experimentai libertar-vos da ignorância e dos flautistas de Hamelin que vos tocam à vara

Filhos de Marx e da Quechua!

Não é todos os dias que vejo alguns jacobinos de sovaco arejado dispostos a derrubar o capitalismo, abolir a propriedade privada, libertar a Palestina, e salvar a humanidade, tudo isto sem abdicar do iphone e das entregas da Uber Eats.  A revolução permanente exige sacrifícios.

Vejo-vos nas praças com keffiehs, arganéis no nariz e uma patusca convicção de superioridade moral. Gritais  “fascismo nunca mais”, e outros resíduos recuperados da lixeira do PREC, mas  não percebeis que sois vós os fascistas, quando exigis que os representantes eleitos do povo, se verguem às vossas birras.

Eu sei que a habitação é apenas o vosso pretexto de ocasião, o que procurais é tempo de antena e protagonismo. Presumo que, nos vossos sonhos húmidos, a revolução imobiliária triunfará quando todos os portugueses forem obrigados  a trocar as suas casas por um T2 da Decathlon, com vista panorâmica para a lixeira.

Admiro a vossa disponibilidade para fazer a revolução enfrentando agruras indescritíveis como a possibilidade de a bateria do iPhone chegar aos 10% e a polícia não reconhecer a soberania da assembleia popular da Praça D. João I.

Trotsky levou com uma picareta na testa, vocês têm falta de carga no telemóvel, a luta é a mesma, mas cada geração tem a épica que merece.

Reparei que nos vossos ajuntamentos, aparecem incontáveis bandeiras palestinianas e keffiehs, embora me escape a relação entre a renda de um T1 em Paranhos e a existência de Israel. Admito contudo que não frequentei o acampamento de Verão do Hamas.

O keffieh da moda revolucionário-chic fica-vos lindamente, aliás, e transmite aquela impressão de compromisso com causas distantes que dispensa o incómodo de as conhecer. Além disso, combina com os ténis de marca e o telemóvel de mil euros. Sugiro-vos porém  um pequeno exercício de imersão cultural. Se gostais tanto dos símbolos de sociedades totalitárias experimentai passar uma tarde com uma burca, que é a vestimenta da moda na terra dos keffiehs. Creio que o vosso entusiasmo pela causa ganharia com um conhecimento mais íntimo daquilo que apoiais.

Haveria inconvenientes, claro. O penteado e as argolas no nariz ficariam invisíveis mas, em contrapartida, teríeis uma ideia aproximada da vida de mulheres que não podem escolher o que vestir. É menos divertido do que uma manifestação no Rossio, mas a revolução exige compromissos.

Lembrais-vos de Mahsa Amini?

É provável que não, faltavam-lhe credenciais. Não usava keffieh, não protestava contra os “sionistas” e não integrava a assembleia popular, mas era uma jovem iraniana de 22 anos, morta há 4 anos pela polícia da moralidade, por não usar correctamente o hijab e por pedir o extravagante direito de decidir o que vestir. As autoridades responderam aos protestos matando centenas de pessoas, uma forma de diálogo social que vos faz assobiar para o ar.

Imaginai a vossa acampada em Teerão ou Gaza. Tenho a certeza de que seria uma experiência pedagógica inesquecível, embora bastante curta.

Ah, tenho uma proposta para o slogan: “Do rio ao mar, as mulheres libertar”?

Não é tão trendy  como o “Fri fri Palestine, bla, bla, bla”, mas corresponde a uma luta contra a verdadeira opressão de verdadeiros vilões.

É também provável que nunca tenhais ouvido falar de Yasmine Mohammed, canadiana obrigada a casar com um islamista que a obrigava a usar o niqab e a agredia por andar sem véu dentro de casa.

Yasmine descreveu o saco de batatas que trazia enfiado na cabeça, como algo que a afastava da humanidade, a impedia de estabelecer contacto visual e sorrir às pessoas.

Isto não aconteceu em Kandahar. Foi no Canadá, país onde as mulheres podem escolher ser ministras ou camionistas, mas há  milhares impedidas sequer de mostrar a cara.

Sabeis dos casamentos forçados, da privação da liberdade e dos crimes de honra cometidos pelos próprios familiares? Sabeis que em 2021, em Portugal, um muçulmano foi condenado a 18 anos de prisão, por bater na mulher e matar o filho que se tentou interpor, alegando que numa família muçulmana a mulher deveria comportar-se como um “cão fiel para o marido”?

Sabeis que são centenas de milhões as raparigas submetidas à mutilação genital em comunidades muçulmanas, por leis e costumes que tratam as mulheres como seres sub-humanos?

A vossa indignação está sujeita à aprovação do comité ideológico? Os maus não são do tipo  que vos faz salivar?

Percebo a dificuldade. Entre os direitos das mulheres e a coerência ideológica, há prioridades que não se discutem e o apoio ao Hamas é uma delas.

Noto também a  presença de activistas LGBT nas vossas procissões pela habitação e pela Palestina. É colorido, dá imensas selfies e likes, mas experimentai organizar uma marcha do orgulho LGBT em Gaza, com bandeiras arco-íris, drag queens, palavras de ordem contra o patriarcado e reivindicações sobre identidade de género e observai, enquanto durardes a diversidade cultural que vos espera.

Já na terra dos sionistas, podeis fazer isso com toda a liberdade mas isto não encontra espaço nos vossos cartazes. Não sobraram canetas depois de escreverem “genocídio” em letras de metro e meio, porque ouviram dizer por aí?

Ah, sim, ouvi-vos acusar Israel de apartheid. Provavelmente não sabeis que os cidadãos árabes de Israel votam, elegem deputados, têm cargos públicos e integram os tribunais, incluindo o Supremo.  E, caramba,  bastavam alguns minutos de atenção à informação disponível. Sim eu sei que 2 minutos a ler são para vocês duas eternidades no TikTok mas a Ritalina serve para isso.

O PREC que macaqueais e que imaginais como um festival de Verão com cantigas de intervenção, sardinhas e jambés, teve ocupações, intimidações, saneamentos políticos,  prisões arbitrárias, torturas, etc. Aqueles que agora chamais fascistas, lutaram pela liberdade que hoje vos permite chamar fascista a qualquer pessoa que discorde de vós.

Eu sei que tendes dificuldade em  perceber isto, mas a contagem dos participantes numa assembleia de meia dúzia de bolcheviques com lenço palestiniano, não está acima dos resultados eleitorais, nem uma praça passa a pertencer-vos porque cinquenta iluminados da penumbra decidiram lá ficar a fazer conchinha e a discutir a abolição do capitalismo e a revolução, entre duas sessões de ganza.

Embora vos custe aceitar, há milhões de portugueses que não participam nas patéticas assembleias populares, estão-se nas tintas para o porta-voz do “colectivo” e, cúmulo da alienação burguesa, insistem em preferir eleições.

No Rossio tentastes linchar um “sionista”, porque tinha uma bandeira. O antissemitismo é antigo, mesmo quando o embrulhais num discurso hipócrita sobre causas e direitos humanos, e o recozeis em ignorância e ódio.

A História, quando não é estudada, tem o péssimo hábito de regressar, disfarçada de moda progressista, para enganar idiotas úteis.

Meus caros proletários da mesada, o que vos peço é apenas que estudeis um bocadinho. O mundo é demasiado complexo para caber num vídeo do Tik Tok. A História é demasiado importante para ser substituída por slogans para mentecaptos. E a liberdade é demasiado preciosa para ser deixada à mercê de quem confunde a própria vontade com a vontade popular.

Antes de libertardes a humanidade, experimentai libertar-vos da ignorância e dos flautistas de Hamelin que vos tocam à vara.

É uma revolução que não exige keffieh nem ocupação de praças, não dá direito a entrevistas na televisão e tem o inconveniente de obrigar a ler livros, a experiência e sabedoria cumulada dos que vos  fizeram desaguar no presente, e não apenas as frases bacocas que circulam no Instagram e que denunciam a vossa ignorância campista.

E quem sabe? Talvez, acabeis por  descobrir que a liberdade foi conquistada com o sangue dos vossos ancestrais, não desceu do céu sobre uma assembleia de tendas, e que o mundo existia antes de teres ido ao chinês comprar o keffiehs com o dinheiro do papá.


Observador - Como sair desta confusão?

 


(sublinhados pessoais)

Como sair desta confusão?

O poder em Portugal é hoje uma casa a que tiraram as portas, e onde qualquer transeunte pode entrar, sentar-se nos cadeirões sob os holofotes, e fazer de conta que é importante.

O que têm em comum os campistas de extrema-esquerda, o presidente da república, e o presidente da câmara municipal de Oeiras? Este facto: todos conseguiram abrir noticiários, ocupar comentadores, fazer o mundo político rodar à volta deles, sem terem poder nem meios ou ideias para resolver os problemas de que falam.

Os campistas, a que se juntaram os comunistas e a sua CGTP, ocuparam praças em Lisboa e Porto. Mas fizeram-no com as mesmas centenas de profissionais de todas as manifestações, e com estribilhos tão velhos como ridículos (tirar as casas aos “ricos”). Comunistas e extrema-esquerda estão reduzidos à expressão mais singela. Os ponteiros das sondagens, que se têm movido para os outros partidos, não se moveram para eles. Ocupam a rua, mas não conseguem sair da rua.

O presidente da república exortou os partidos a entenderem-se sobre a habitação. Abriu telejornais, mas os partidos ignoraram-no, e a recepção ao campismo em Belém pareceu um acto de desespero para não sair do noticiário. Com todo o respeito pessoal e institucional que merece, ninguém lhe reconhece muita força. Foi eleito com 66% dos votos, mas na segunda volta, em que, contra Ventura, outro candidato teria tido resultado parecido: quando havia mais candidatos por onde escolher, teve 31%, e isto apesar de não ter rival na sua área política (em 1986, Mário Soares também só teve 25% dos votos na primeira volta, mas a concorrer à esquerda contra Salgado Zenha e Lurdes Pintasilgo).

Finalmente, o novo partido suscitou muitos comentários, mas quase só espirituosos. Esse partido ainda no ventre de Oeiras, as exortações presidenciais ou o campismo extremista nunca teriam tido o tempo de antena que tiveram, não fosse a situação política de impasse e deriva que amplifica qualquer fait-divers e assim estimula as “iniciativas”. O poder em Portugal é hoje uma casa a que tiraram as portas, e onde todo o transeunte pode entrar, sentar-se nos cadeirões sob os holofotes, e fazer de conta que é importante.

Só um governo assente numa maioria dissipará a confusão presente. Essa maioria, porém, não pode ser ela própria mais uma confusão. Mas é confusão que obtemos, quando, pela improbabilidade da maioria absoluta de um só, emparelhamos os partidos. O chamado “Bloco Central”, por exemplo. Nunca seria mais do que um expediente defensivo de PS e PSD perante uma vitória do Chega. Mas só aconteceria se o PSD se submetesse ao PS, porque o PS nunca aceitou ser segundo em acordos com outros partidos. Em 1983-1986, não foi fácil. Hoje, seria ainda mais difícil: o actual PS não é o PS de Mário Soares, anti-comunista e comprometido com o FMI, mas o PS da guerra à “troïka” e da “geringonça”. A união de PSD e PS serviria apenas para dividir cada um deles. Quanto a um bloco PSD-Chega, é inviável com os actuais líderes depois do que aconteceu desde 2025. Mas após novas eleições, não seria mais fácil, caso o Chega passasse à frente e insistisse em fazer valer o seu avanço: nenhum líder do PSD estaria tranquilo em segundo lugar.

Os partidos, tal como estão, não se conjugam. Estamos habituados a jogar com eles como se fossem as únicas peças da política. Não são, sobretudo quando lhes falta dirigentes fortes ou capazes de ir além da sua tribo. É tempo de pensarmos também em pessoas, como nas democracias com muitos partidos, e nenhum maioritário – isto é, políticos que, independentemente dos seus compromissos partidários, tenham credibilidade e autoridade pessoal para combinar os grupos existentes numa maioria. À direita, há pelo menos um político nessas condições: chama-se Pedro Passos Coelho. Se não pudermos contar com pessoas assim, ficar-nos-emos pelo impasse e mais campismo.

The Spectator - Revolting France: The riots are driving the country’s politics to its extremes

 

(personal highlights)

Revolting France: The riots are driving the country’s politics to its extremes

The wonderful thing about electric bikes, if you are fighting with French riot police, is the way they burn. You skid your Lime or Vélib’ into the middle of the Boulevard de Magenta, which leads from the Gare du Nord down to the Place de la République, and set it alight along with a pile of ordinary bikes, and soon you have a conflagration of rubber and battery chemicals.

During the weekend’s street protests, the fires provided cover for rioters breaking into mobile phone, vape and jewellery stores and the money-transfer shops which serve the many immigrants who work in eastern Paris. By Monday morning, a vicious guard dog stood outside an Intermarché supermarket, snarling at customers coming in one by one. A diagnostic lab had its windows smashed in; a children’s nursery was covered in graffiti. Outside the building where Louis Daguerre produced his first daguerreotype, three cars and a small delivery van were burned out, one of the cars flipped onto its roof.

The graffiti spoke for itself. ‘Revolution’. ‘Macron: Give Us the Money’. ‘No future, No Peace’. ‘The Kids Have Talent’. ‘Capitalism Kills’. ‘Nique Un Facho (Fuck a Fascist)’. ‘It’s Okay to Punch Nazis’. ‘Power = Paedophile’. The Monument to the Republic, the great statue at the centre of the Place de la République, was covered in similar slogans. Égalité looked like a zombie, her eyes and cheeks smeared in black paint. La République now wore a yellow worker’s vest with the words: ‘The Police Are Mutilating the Students’. In the smart shopping neighbourhoods near the Champs-Élysées, the rioters had gone for labels, Burberry, Dior, Kenzo, Celine. In the Lacoste store on Boulevard des Capucines, they left the message ‘Fauchés mais en Lacoste’ (‘Broke but in Lacoste’).

What happened was not a revolution, it was a failure of policing. What started in mid-September as a peaceful demonstration against the government for its failure to invest in schools and stop the upward spiral of fuel prices has turned into weeks of riots and street fights, with the police unable to keep up. Criminal gangs took advantage of the chaos, as they tend to. The kids stealing iPhones and handbags and yelling ‘Where’s Chanel?’ as they sprinted towards the Avenue Montaigne were clearly not the ones demanding more investment in the baccalauréat programme. There was nothing of the long-haired, tight-sweatered socialist spirit of 1968 Paris about them. The overwhelming number of looters caught by the police were men between 18 and 30, many with criminal records. For them, the protests were cover for a day of violence. For others, the chaos could be hijacked for a different cause, as evidenced by the large number of Palestine flags and keffiyehs.

In 2019, the French police created a special unit to deal with just this kind of situation, the Brigade de Répression de l’Action Violente Motorisée, a division on small fast motorbikes, capable of chasing rioters down narrow streets. But they were outrun and outsmarted by leaderless packs, seething across the city, merging and breaking up into larger and smaller groups. Why, exactly, the police failed has become a guessing game. Did the government allow the riots to let rip in order to make the left look bad? Was it a botched ploy to send shivers through the electorate and drive them in from the extremities of left and right, to the security of the emptied middle ground? Or were the police just too slow?

Whatever the reason, the chaos has been a complete humiliation for President Emmanuel Macron and a boon for his enemies. Marine Le Pen is still often described as a far-right leader, but the label is misleading. Her ideas and her party, the Rassemblement National, have become the centre of gravity in French politics. If next spring’s presidential elections were held this week, she would win easily. On Sunday, she spoke with that strong pub landlady vibe which seems to so resonate with French voters. It is closing time in France, and she is not having any of it. She called the riots ‘a threat to democracy’, blaming them on ‘decades of immigration’ and a weak government ‘incapable of doing anything other than commenting on its own impotence’.

President Macron, for his part, gave a televised address with all the authority of a flustered cabin steward, before setting off on Monday to the Gulf to plead for more diesel and oil. The word most often hurled at him now, and not just by Le Pen, is ‘powerless’. With six months left in his final term, he has run out of authority and ideas. It did not help that he spent Friday night with his wife at a Celine Dion concert, hardly the excursion of a leader in a time of crisis. He was accompanied by Hélène Mercier-Arnault, the wife of Bernard Arnault, the head of LVMH and France’s richest man. While the left was preparing its placards and Dion was singing ‘My Heart Will Go On’, Macron’s reputation hit new depths.

Very simply, France is in a deep financial hole. Successive governments have broken the country’s entrepreneurial spirit and the nation’s debts have piled up. It already has the second-highest tax to GDP ratio and personal income tax rates in Europe, after Denmark, as well as the most national debt. It has consistently breached the EU’s borrowing limits, and now the costs of that borrowing are rising as investors dump French government bonds. Arguing over the absence of white players on the national football team is a proxy for any serious discussion of France’s hopeless integration of its post-colonial immigrants, and it seems particularly pointless at a moment when rising inflation is exposing the country’s fundamental economic rot.

The student protestors are right to be furious that a third of France’s education budget goes on pensions. The kids, as the graffiti said, have talent. Silicon Valley and New York are full of clever young French people, beautifully trained in science and maths. But they have left France with good reason. All the early hopes that Macron would have the political verve and intellectual sophistication to reform the state fizzled out a long time ago. He promised that his policies would reinforce the centre and make the political extremes meaningless. Now the favourites for the final two candidates in 2027 are his old right-wing nemesis Le Pen and Jean-Luc Mélenchon, leader of the far-left La France Insoumise.

He promised the business class that he would make France more welcoming to the entrepreneurial and the aspirational. It is true that he cut corporate taxes, championed a French start-up culture and listened to the rich when they threatened to leave the country if he raised taxes on wealth. But under his presidency, economic growth has staggered along at around the EU average, far behind the US.

Macron has always been a solitary force, oddly friendless, convinced of his own brilliance. The weekend’s events were likely his tombstone, and he has no natural heir on his right. Lurking offstage, though, is another investment banker, like Macron, but this time on the left. Matthieu Pigasse has followed the classic route for the French ruling class. He is an énarque, educated at the École Nationale d’Administration, who spent his early career as an adviser at the Ministry of Finance, before joining Lazard Frères, specialising in sovereign debt restructuring and corporate mergers and acquisitions. Along the way, he invested in media, picking up stakes in publishing and radio. He is 58, ten years older than Macron, but said to be deeply envious of the President’s achievements.

Pigasse has drifted from the centre left of the Parti Socialiste to the hard left, while he spends his summer holidays on the Caribbean island of Mustique. He claims to be leading a necessary culture war against the extreme right and has encouraged his media outlets, notably his radio station, Radio Nova, to embrace controversy. A few days before the weekend protests, his hosts joked about kidnapping the business tycoons Arnault and Vincent Bolloré from their homes and dragging them through the streets by their silk ties. They also suggested protestors force the chief executives of France’s largest companies into a game of dodgeball, in which they hurled the ball at their heads. Pigasse has made a fortune as a conventional banker, but proposes that France solve many of its economic problems by unilaterally cancelling about 20 per cent of its public debt, held by the European Central Bank and the Bank of France. The idea is popular with the far left, but considered absurd by conventional economists. He is friends with Mélenchon and is said to have introduced him to Hugo Chávez.

Pigasse was excluded from the presidential primaries by the Parti Socialiste, but he has the resources for an independent run. He said recently that, with months to go before the election, nothing is off the table. His record is one of ambition rather than consistency. Emerging from the burned tyres and bike batteries of the weekend, he has the makings of France’s next insider outsider: a pure cynic, entirely of the system, leading another charade of change.

Philip Delves Broughton is a former Paris correspondent for the Daily Telegraph. His new book, Embargo, is out on 29 October.

Gatos

 

































The Spectator - The real reason the US is withdrawing its bombers from Britain

 

(personal highlights)

The real reason the US is withdrawing its bombers from Britain

Armed police form a road block at RAF Fairford after the thwarted attack (Getty images)

As the old gag goes, “Just because you’re paranoid, it doesn’t mean that they’re not after you”; in other words, more than one thing can be true at the same time. So too, with the ongoing saga of the withdrawal of US aircraft from first RAF Fairford, in Gloucestershire, and now, RAF Mildenhall, in Suffolk.

In the Red Corner, there are those who are quick to point out that redeployment of scarce assets is ‘normal business’, and dispersal of aircraft, under some kind of threat is also routine. In the rather fetching Turquoise Corner, is Reform’s new defence spokesman, a recently retired RAF Regiment officer, someone who can reasonably be expected to know something about defending airfields, who lambasts the government for so failing to protect our country, that our closest military ally is forced to move its aircraft.

There is some truth in Angus MacIntyre’s accusations, as there is as also in the bromidic statements of the “nothing to see here”, brigade: routine redeployments are common but especially so if there are vague threats that can’t be easily quantified or mitigated against: “move now, route to follow”, is a hoary old military maxim. There is also no doubt about the Iranian threat.

The thwarted attack, if that is what it was, at RAF Fairford might seem amateurish and poorly executed but, evidently, it didn’t need to be more effective: the potential for a ground attack or, more likely, a drone attack was enough.

The very reasonable concern was that the Iranians would attempt a reprise of the highly successful Ukrainian operation, Operation Spiderweb of June 2025, that used unwitting Russian drivers to deliver apparently commercial loads close to Russian strategic bases. The loads turned-out to be ‘Wooden Horses’, containing 117 drones that caused $7 billion (£5.3 billion) worth of damage to Russian strategic aircraft, including nuclear-capable bombers, at airfields as remote from Kiev, as Murmansk in the North, to Irkutsk, close to Mongolia. Both the US B1 Bombers and KC-135 aircraft fit into the same ‘high-value’ target category and they are vulnerable: the bases are unhardened; and we have an active, and malevolent, Iranian intelligence presence, which the government seems unwilling to completely squash and is struggling to control. The Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps qua organisation was finally proscribed formally in July this year but it is still not illegal to belong to it, an astonishing lacuna.

In the circumstances, the US moves could be said to be acting out of an abundance of reasonable caution. But there is something else going on too.

In Abu Dhabi this week, the latest round of US-brokered Russia-Ukraine peace talks, included within it the demand, from Russia, that any peace settlement must encompass a comprehensive restructuring of the defence and security architecture in Europe, a demand that President Trump seems willing to go along with,

“It’s going to be a big agreement and it’s going to involve more than Ukraine,” he said. Not for the first time, Trump appears to be working from the same speaking notes as President Putin; he is, for example, willing to accept Putin’s demands that the Europeans, who would be most affected, are not to be part of any negotiation. 

“No one is going to invite them to the negotiating table”, Kremlin foreign affairs advisor, Yuri Ushakov, has declared and Trump has not demurred.

In the background, there is also the quiet withdrawal and redistribution of US forces in Europe: as at Apr 2025, there were some 80,000 US service personnel in Europe, down from the 105,000 immediately after the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.

Peter Hegseth, the Secretary for War, wishes to reduce this number further; tellingly, eight air-to-air refuelling tankers were slated for withdrawal in a plan outlined in July this year, along with a complete bombing group, and 50 of the 150 fighters currently based in Europe.

The official line from the US is that they are “rightsizing” the US contribution to Nato. But as has been made abundantly clear, the US has, with good reason, become tired of Europe’s apparent indifference to its own defence.

“I fully share your loathing of European free-loading. It’s pathetic”, is how Pete Hegseth put it to a group of national security heads, in the summer of 2025, including Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Vice President JD Vance.

The US, under Trump, has also made it clear that Nato’s Article V, hitherto regarded as the cornerstone of Nato’s collective defence is not a cast-iron guarantee: support for other countries is dependent on them being primarily responsible for their own defence and actively supporting the US when it decides to act in the world.

By this standard, many European countries, including Britain, fall short; forcing them to change is why the US are pushing so hard for the new ‘Nato 3.0 Framework’, the bottom line of which is that European countries are responsible for their own conventional defence.

This is where all these threads start to come together. While the intelligence is murky, some form of credible Iranian threat to US bases is probable and the US, prudently, withdrew some of its most valuable, and vulnerable, aircraft to put them beyond harm’s reach.

But this, an essentially tactical move, disguises a strategic shift of US support from Europe – which it deems capable of its own self-defence – towards the Western Hemisphere and Asia-Pacific region. Along the way, as a way of accelerating this process, Trump seeks a grand bargain with Putin, with the latter ‘guaranteeing’ peace in Europe, provided of course he gets his way: a, at best, etiolated and emasculated Ukraine; Nato withdrawal from Eastern Europe; and a recognition of Russia as, once again, a ‘Great Power’.

Withdrawing the US aircraft, with all the attendant, and not completely unfair, criticism it has attracted, allows the narrative of ‘unreliable allies’ to be reinforced; this, in turn feeds into the justification for the wider desire to unshackle the US from a commitment to Europe.

Trump came to power with strong messages of ‘America First’ and ’No More Forever Wars’: many commentators nodded wisely when these things were said and assumed it meant, despite the recent intervention in Iran, the Middle East. Actually, it is clear, he and his team also meant Europe. The Iranian attacks could not be more timely for the US: the Civil Service are wont to say, “Never waste a good crisis.”, and US are milking this one for all it is worth.

Céus

 




quinta-feira, 19 de novembro de 2026

Reflexão - São

 






Em 1960 ou 1961, não me recordo bem, quando entrei para o colégio de Freiras em Belém, isto antes de ingressar no Colégio Alemão na Rua do Passadiço e mais tarde em Telheiras, quando a carrinha me foi buscar pela primeira vez à "rua Particular...", a minha ama recordava sempre, como eu contava, que quando entrei na carrinha para me levarem, "eu limpei as lágrimas ao bibe". Isto a propósito de ter sido separado, pela primeira vez em que tive esse sentimento (...), de quem me protegia e tratava na altura.

Hoje, 20.11.2026, quando estava na aula de Hidroginástica na piscina do Monte de Caparica, não limpei as lágrimas ao bibe. Dissolveram-se simplesmente na água, ao ouvir o "não me esqueci de ti" do Rui Veleoso. 


segunda-feira, 16 de novembro de 2026

The Spectator - How Prague cured me of my communism


 

(personal highlights)

How Prague cured me of my communism

Proust can keep his soggy madeleine. For me the word ‘Prague’ is a trigger of memory like no other. It stirs me up like some plaintive half-heard tune, or the faint scent of lavender in sheets left folded for years.

Evil news from Prague, in another stuffy August long ago, turned my world over completely. This was 1968, a year of wonders, none of them very nice, which will not easily leave my recollection. It was the year I joined a Trotskyist sect. It was the year I punched a man (in self defence). It was the year I attended my first violent raucous demonstration, against the war in Vietnam, with the police horses thundering through the March mud in Grosvenor Square. A few weeks later Paris was full of tear gas and flying cobblestones, and how I wished I was there. It was an age when, if your head was not hot, you weren’t thinking or fully alive. I was on the wrong side – and I was on the right side. I will never be able to unscramble the messy omelette of opinions I then held, to separate the good from the bad.

Then came Prague, and the Soviet tanks flattening a brief flowering of freedom, just about this time of year. I knew, or thought I knew, that revolutionary socialism did not need to lead to the cement-headed repression of the USSR. I despised that as a tyranny and a failure. Freedom under communism was like fire under water. But what was this mysterious city, Prague?

My geography lessons had been traditional, about the Empire or the Home Islands, so that I knew much of the Western Ghats or the Carse of Gowrie, and nothing of the Danube or the Carpathians. Now I was learning about a part of Europe I had never previously considered, and beginning to understand that it might be important in my life. And like a grey haze just behind the modern headlines, I could also see another Prague and another Czech crisis, in another stifling late summer then (amazingly) only 30 years before.

In 1968, the Munich crisis was about as distant in time as Princess Diana’s divorce from the present King is now. I imagined Prague’s baroque towers in a dark bend of the river Vltava, but what we saw on our TV screens was a jazzy city mainly of the 1930s, lots of glass and concrete, streamlined yet old-fashioned, and now full of stupid violence and righteous anger. Film of a tank smashing into a barricade of trams, as if it were made of biscuit tins, made me realise for the first time what a terrifying thing a tank must be. I had never before seen shameless power being exercised in plain sight.

In Vietnam you saw the bombs going off in the distance and heard the crackle of gunfire, but here people in civilian clothes, much like us, were being intimidated by iron-faced men in armoured vehicles, while their leaders were carted off in manacles to Moscow. We were all outraged. I remember fiddling late one evening with our elderly wireless, which had one of those illuminated dials promising transmissions from Kalundborg, Hilversum, Athlone, Droitwich, Königsberg… and Prague. I hoped absurdly to pick up a last whisper of protest on the night airwaves. Shocked and distressed as we were, we knew that our government would do nothing, because at Yalta we had promised to stay out. We hated what was happening, but our anger was empty and so rather shameful.

Partly for that reason, I never forgot it, and ten years later, when the chance came to go to Prague itself, I had to go. I really owe the journey to Evelyn Jones, wife of the once-mighty trade union leader Jack, and a friend of my wife’s parents. Evelyn had been a courier for the Comintern in the 1930s, carrying messages to Moscow from western communists and bringing gold back. She said: ‘You must go to Prague. Nowhere else still has the spirit of Europe between the wars. It is utterly beautiful and surprisingly easy to get to.’ As I was by then a Fleet Street journalist, my visa took some weeks to arrive, while the Czech secret police dismantled, photocopied and reassembled my passport. As we planned our railway journey (Paris, Heidelberg, Nuremberg) we noticed that the official map stopped at the Iron Curtain – from Nuremberg there was just an arrow pointing to ‘Praha’.

So, on an early spring day our train crossed from dozy Franconia into the evil empire, through a web of barbed wire, and if I had not thought this was an evil empire before, I certainly did then. The country was a sort of prison. Men in grey uniforms swarmed over, through and under the carriages, searching every corner of the train and every pocket and bag of the passengers. The seats were hard plastic. The compartments were decorated with a large Red Star. The cities we passed through were smoke-blackened and hung with red-and-white propaganda banners. Our fellow passengers had stainless-steel teeth.

As we ran into the outskirts of Prague, we began to see Soviet railway carriages marked with the hammer and sickle, and to feel as if we were being pulled into the orbit of a darker sun. As we rode the tram from Wenceslas Square to our hotel, we were approached and befriended by the first secret police spy I have knowingly met. Later we would meet all kinds of other people, one of them almost in tears about the comfort the BBC World Service brought him, another an Anglophile black Cuban comrade on an exchange, anxious to share his splendid rum. (We did so. The rum broke several language barriers at once.)

Beyond all this lay the city, oddly reminiscent of Oxford with its crooked, narrow streets, bells and spires, best seen from the hill above, much of it black and held up only by ancient scaffolding. The communists did not treasure it. There were no tourists. The staple diet seemed to be dumplings. It reeked of oppression. We learned for the first time what it is like to be afraid to say what you think. And it did indeed whisper from its towers the last enchantments of the 1930s, as Evelyn Jones had promised. History, the real, dangerous sort that frightens and unsettles you, came rushing into my mind – and all this in the middle of one of the most movingly beautiful places I had ever seen. I am sorry, but you cannot go there now. The modern world has scrubbed it clean of the past. But we will always have Prague, the greatest history lesson I ever experienced.

domingo, 15 de novembro de 2026

The Spectator - Michel Houellebecq and the tyranny of Islamist sensitivity

 

(personal highlights)

(LBC) - Question: and there is only one Houellebecq?? Good grief!

Michel Houellebecq and the tyranny of Islamist sensitivity

French writer Michel Houellebecq (Getty images)

They’re coming for Michel Houellebecq again. The rumpled, chain-smoking laureate of misery is once more in the crosshairs of the French state for causing offence. I’ll give you one guess who he’s offended. That’s right: Muslims. Islam really has become the premier snowflake religion, a faith so exquisitely fragile that even a grumpy novelist puffing on a Gauloise in a Parisian cafe can give its clerics a fit of the vapours.

Houellebecq has been formally charged by a judge in Nanterre, near Paris, for comments he made in 2022. Houellebecq, who denies the charges, was chatting with the philosopher Michel Onfray for the magazine Front Populaire. As is his wont – and as should be his God-given right – he had a pop at Islam. The “great replacement” is not a theory, he said: it’s a “statistical” fact. And its consequences, he mused, will be dire.

This is where the conversation got genuinely incendiary. Houellebecq said that if France falls to “Islamist control”, there will be “acts of resistance”. He said there could be “shootings in mosques, in cafes frequented by Muslims”. “In short, Bataclans in reverse”, he said, referring to the 2015 Isis massacre at the Bataclan in Paris in which 90 souls perished.

It was explosive stuff, there’s no question of that: bleak, provocative and designed to make polite society gag on their Sauvignon Blanc. Which they did. The interview caused a storm when it was first published four years ago. Both leftists and imams slammed Houellebecq as crass and bigoted. Fine. Take offence. That’s your right. But a writer’s thoughts – no matter how raw or lurid – should never be the business of the state.

Yet that’s what has happened. The judge has put Houellebecq under investigation for “complicity in incitement to discrimination, hatred or violence”. This follows a complaint lodged by the Union of Mosques of France. “Certain types of rhetoric” can “prime minds for violence”, said the Union. They can create an “ideological breeding ground for terrorist acts”. Yes, because nothing whips up a militia like an ageing enfant terrible sighing into a little-read philosophical quarterly. 

The investigation of Houellebecq is outrageous. He clearly was not inciting violence – he was speculating about future social friction. He wasn’t issuing a call to arms – he was issuing a bleak, typically Houellebecqian prognosis. It is a grotesque intrusion into freedom of thought to charge a man for wondering out loud if social collapse beckons. Should French magistrates kick down the doors of every gloomy poet and dystopian scribbler who fails to peddle the state line that the future will be fab?

If a writer isn’t free to stare into the abyss and report back what he sees, then liberty is dead already. It matters not one iota whether you agree or disagree with Houellebecq. You don’t have to share his bleak worldview. You just need to defend his right to be bleak. 

Free speech isn’t a dinner-party nicety reserved for those who say soothing, comforting things. It is an iron shield for the heretic, the pessimist, the provocateur. It is all or nothing. It must be enjoyed by both the misanthrope and the optimist. By both the court flatterer and the cynical iconoclast. By both Islam’s followers and grumpy old novelists who think Islam is “the stupidest religion”.

That was Houellebecq too. In a 2001 interview he said Islam is dumb. And he was put on trial. In 21st-century France a man was dragged into the dock for making fun of a religion. It was an Inquisition of Islamophobia. Mercifully he was acquitted. The Muslim leaders who initiated the tyrannical action were horrified. But he was “deliberately insulting”, they said. And? In a free society, the people’s right to mock Islam should take precedence over the feelings of Muslims, every single time.

If we are only free to speak so long as we stay within the state-decreed boundaries of “acceptable thought”, then we’re not free at all. We don’t have the freedom to speak but a licence to speak. A licence that can be revoked the minute you blaspheme against Islam or rub up against any of the shifting orthodoxies of polite society. True liberty isn’t the freedom to echo the consensus – it’s the freedom to be heretical without suffering the wrath of the state or the mob.

Here’s the thing: if a faith cannot survive a mordant Frenchman calling it silly without going crying to the courts, then the problem is the faith, not those who mock it. Religion of Peace? More like the Religion of Perpetual Umbrage. It feels like we live under a tyranny of Islamist sensitivity, aided and abetted by a cowardly state and intellectuals who long ago fed liberty into the mangle of “diversity”. 

In such circumstances, blasphemy is not merely a right we should grudgingly tolerate – it’s a democratic duty. Blasphemy is the ultimate test of freedom, the pinprick that deflates clerical pomposity and reminds zealots that their sacred cows are another man’s hamburger. Houellebecq is not a dangerous tyrant – he is a servant of liberty.

Reflexão - Marco Rubio speech

A premonitory speech?... so it seems to me




The Spectator - Nobody goes to Wimbledon for the tennis

 


Nobody goes to Wimbledon for the tennis

It’s all about the aesthetic

(iStock)

Two hours and 17 minutes after arriving at Wimbledon, I realise I hate tennis. Hate it? I loathe it. All ‘40-love’ jargon and thwack thwack of a ball. It’s football without the pack mentality. Badminton with better PR.  

‘Why are you even here then?’ asks an Argentinian tennis agent when I say this by the players’ lounge. ‘This is the oldest tournament in the world! It’s the best!’ He’s right. He’s an international expert so of course he’s right. Even if all his singles players were knocked out by day three. 

But, of course, that’s exactly why I’m here. Because no one – or very few at least – really come to SW19 for the tennis. They come to drink Pimm’s in the sun; to fan themselves on Henman Hill; to join queue after queue after queue.  

Ah, the queues. The endless queues. Like socialism, they never quite go away. There’s The Queue, of course (one sleep-deprived spectator tells me they waited for eight hours to get in). But then there are all the others – to see Venus Williams on Court 14, to try the IBM ‘AI fan experience’ (whatever, exactly that is), to buy Stella Artois from its own-branded bar. Worst of all is the shop, selling every conceivable piece of merchandise from fresh cut grass diffusers to Babolat sports bags. ‘What’s the most expensive thing here?’ I whisper to one of the shop assistants from – you guessed it – a queue. She points to an enormous plushy strawberry with a cartoon grimace: ‘I’m pretty sure that’s like £500.’ Has anyone bought one? ‘God, no.’ Can she get one for free if she works here? ‘No! I just look at them instead.’ 

Then 1 p.m. strikes and the real tennis, the proper stuff, hits off. Naomi Osaka struts onto Court 1 in an embroidered jacket, bell sleeves and a floaty white train to thrash Daria Kasatkina in two sets. Over on Centre, the crowd (which includes Rishi Sunak in the royal box) roars for Novak Djokovic, who stumbles his way to history with a record-equalling 105th win over Arthur Rinderknech. World number ones Jannik Sinner and Aryna Sabalenka sail several serves closer to the final. All while the sun beats down at 27C and the smell of lukewarm white wine grows stronger in the stands… 

Or so I imagine. I’m not watching. Nor are most of the 40,000-plus ‘fans’ here. They’re all off court, trying to get the most out of their £1 reusable cups. Eating their M&S picnics in the walled garden. Munching on miso roasted tofu or chicken karaage or, of course, strawberries and cream from the food market. They’re not, they’re definitely not, watching the tennis.  

It’s a bizarre beast Wimbledon. A perfectly-mown relic from Victorian times that still glitters in the modern age. The first ‘Wimbledon’ took place in 1877, at the All England Croquet and Lawn Tennis Club (now better known by its acronym AELTC) round the corner on Worple Road. A tournament of 22 male players expanded to include women and doubles the following decade. Players including British brothers Reggie and Laurie Doherty (known as the ‘gentlemen of the courts’) and America’s May Sutton (crowned the first international champion in 1905) became sporting celebrities. By the time the AELTC moved to its current site on Church Road in 1922, the self-proclaimed aesthetic of Wimbledon – tennis in an English garden – was as alluring as the tennis itself. And continues to be to this day, serving up grass champions from Evonne Goolagong to Serena Williams, John McEnroe to Andy Murray. 

So traditional is Wimbledon that long-forgotten traditions are being remembered every year. Journalist Sarah Edworthy tells me that each year’s opening match isn’t only played by the reigning champions but is chaired by whichever umpire presided over the previous final. ‘Not very many people knew that until this year,’ she says. ‘Even the club historian didn’t know.’ 

And yet, somehow, Wimbledon’s power persists: straddling the gap between 19th-century conventionality and contemporary culture wars. That’s not to say it’s always succeeded. Arguments over unisex lavatories, dropped honorifics and the ban on Russian players in 2022 have erupted in recent years. ‘Sustainability’ remains the championship’s buzzword, with a pledge to reach net zero by 2030. It’s all so very ‘woke’, all so very gentrified. And yet still, generation after generation return, for the tea parties and the all-white dress code. For a slice of decorum and conventional order (however corporate-factured) in a city forever losing it.  

As the afternoon begins to cool and the crowds thin towards Southfields station, one of the players sneaks out of the media centre and weaves towards the exit. I don’t see who it is, so I ask a starstruck woman to my left. ‘It’s… oh my God… I can’t… I can’t remember his name!’ She seems to be struggling to breathe. ‘We like him, though. He’s a good guy.’  

I ask another woman in white, holding a punnet of strawberries in one hand, taking a photo with her phone in the other. ‘Oh, I don’t know, I was taking a picture of the view,’ she says with an American drawl. ‘They can’t have been that famous, though.’ 

Apparently it was Sinner. I didn’t see him. I can’t confirm. But neither, apparently, can half of the other ‘fans’ here.  

The Spectator - The problem with the Beatles

 

(personal highlights)

LBC - Could these be the beginnings of the end times?

The problem with the Beatles

A pungent sentimentality has taken hold of their legacy

It’s become hard to imagine that there was once a time when the Beatles were more or less just another 1960s group. For most of the 1970s and 1980s, the Fabs were neither overly fêted nor weirdly fetishised. Writer and filmmaker Grant McPhee recently posted a fascinating Substack detailing how sidelined they became in Liverpool during this period. McPhee recounts Roger Eagle, co-owner of the pivotal punk club Eric’s, expressly telling young musicians such as Ian McCulloch not to listen to them.

Reverence was thin on the ground. Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band and Revolver had not yet been dully canonised as the Best Albums Ever Made; the Red and Blue compilations, released in 1973, were about as much Beatles as most people really needed.

John Lennon was deemed creatively redundant at the time of his murder in 1980. Reviews of Double Fantasy, released three weeks before his death, were damning: Charles Shaar Murray in the NME called it ‘a lousy record’; others described it as ‘dismal’ and ‘smug’. In the years that followed, the three remaining Beatles were widely regarded as old farts (rock stars in their forties!) with mullets.

To paraphrase Bob Dylan: they were so much older then, they’re younger than that now. What changed? Having demolished the original Cavern Club in 1973, a decade later Liverpool City Council finally awoke to the tourism benefits of birthing the Beatles. The compact disc gave the catalogue new impetus while the arrival of glossy monthly music mags minted the notion of ‘legacy rock’. The Beatles Anthology TV series in 1995 began the process of cultural curation in earnest. The internet proved a powerful accelerant.

The emollients of time and distance have gradually allowed a pungent sentimentality to take hold. I’ve always related to Lennon’s characterisation of the Beatles as ‘the biggest bastards on Earth’ – instead, they have become All You Need Is Love™. Peter Jackson’s Get Back Disney doc, which aired in 2021, was a very intentional piece of filmmaking, marketed to challenge the narrative that the Beatles could ever have been beastly to each other.

Behind it all, Apple Corps has continued ruthlessly exploiting the brand. On the one hand, it peddles deeply granular product for Boomers and Gen Xers, the die hards whose knowledge of the band is rooted in a sense of historical authenticity.

For these old lags, however, the pickings have become increasingly slim. Earlier this month saw the release of Rubber Soul: Special Edition. What is special about it, mainly, is the price: the ‘super deluxe’ box costs £125 (CD) or £189 (vinyl). For this you get three versions of the 1965 album (the original mono mix; a new stereo mix; and the jumbled-up US edition) plus a disc of demos and outtakes. The latter includes one genuine rarity – Lennon’s wafer-thin ‘Little Girl’ – and new mixes of contemporaneous singles, ‘Day Tripper’ and ‘We Can Work It Out’.

The set exists not because there is any pressing artistic need for it, but because there is a commercial opportunity to exploit. Grumbling fans talk of a ‘premium Beatles tax’ even while paying it. They will buy The Third Eye, a new book of early photographs by George Harrison, and tickets for McCartney’s game but increasingly ropey live show, which strives to cover all Beatle bases single-handedly. They wait patiently for the second instalment of Mark Lewisohn’s moment-to-moment biographical opus, Tune In, and debate the merits of the ‘new’ Beatles single, ‘Here And Now’, cobbled together from an old Lennon demo and finally completed in 2023 using AI.

Meanwhile, Gen Zed has happily invented its own version of the band, reframed to suit their own needs and sensibilities. TikTok and YouTube are awash with ‘first-time listening’ reaction videos and frenetic, fast-moving Beatles content. These new fans hear echoes of their own contemporary favourites in the back catalogue, enjoy the weird sonic flourishes, incessant genre hopping and complexity of the main characters. Hip London duo Worldpeace DMT are not alone in using Fab ‘lore’ to indulge in hare-brained Beatles fetishism; one of their songs is called ‘Bigger Than Jesus’.

For this market, watching Jackson’s languorous documentary was like hanging out with an idealised family or friend group of weird, zonked-out creatives – Ket Back, perhaps. Likewise, while longstanding Beatles fans are already griping about the four Sam Mendes films focusing on each individual member, due in 2028, a cast including Paul Mescal as McCartney and Barry Keoghan as Ringo suggests that they are not the optimum market.

The Beatles will only become more detached from historic reality. The analogue version of what they once were is worn out. It is being subsumed by a super-deluxe edition, remixed and remastered for the future. Fair enough. Enough Beatles for the Boomers. Time to hand them over.